Would you prefer steel tents or the aluminum ones? Choice is yours; that actually matters. One can go for any tent for an outside portable setup. But the purpose of every setup requires different details and facilities. There are multiple types of tents in the UAE that serve each objective with its acquired details.
In short, the purpose and the tent properties are the main factors determining the suitable one. Al Mawsim Tents explains the steel and aluminium tents through a quick comparison. You can use it as a guide before deciding on a tent. It will make the choice easy!
Steel tents vs Aluminium tents
Steel tents in uae are renowned for their heavy weight and high resilience. These characteristics make them stable and reliable for permanent installations. Steel, being a dense material, gives them resistance against high pressure, forceful collision, and extreme weather.
Aluminium tents, made of a non-ferrous metal, are lightweight and easily adjustable. These features make them ready for on-the-go and short-term arrangements. Despite the low density, they have enough strength to withstand normal wind and weather.
Strength
The steel tents in uae possess high endurance due to their sturdy steel material. Their strength is related to their balance and durability. The secure footing keeps them standing on the ground for a long duration, even in a storm.
Their durability describes the quality of material that gives them resistance to a number of elements. Moreover, they remain intact even after their exposure to these forces. The elements are:
- Tension
- Fire
- Temperature
- Weather
Aluminum tents possess excellent strength in accordance with their weight. However, it is less stable than steel tents in uae. The extra layers of aluminum are added to cope with their low weight. This makes them strong as well as too difficult to mold. They are also resistant to a number of factors, although their resistance to some elements is less than that of the steel tents. They are:
- Tension-resistant
- Water-resistant
- Corrosion-resistant
Rust & Reliability
Galvanized or sometimes powder-coated layers prevent steel tents from corrosion and extend their lifespan. In the absence of these layers, the chances of corrosion increase. However, with or without protective layers, regular care is also essential. Check it from time to time, for even scratches can harm its durability.
Aluminum has a natural resistance to corrosion, which decreases the probability of damage, leading to a longer lifespan of aluminum tents. Moreover, less regular care is required to keep them maintained.
Mass & Mobility
Being markedly heavier, the steel tent is used for setups where minimal relocation and mobility are required. Its bulky features slow down its installation, rearrangements, and transportation. So it is preferably used where the setup requires less mobility.
Being less dense, it is easy to construct and move aluminium tents. It brings them to be ergonomic, fast, and budget-friendly. They can seamlessly be uninstalled from one place and reinstalled on another in case of emergency or extreme weather.
Cost
Hurdles in transportation, corrosion treatment, and regular maintenance add up to its cost. This added cost is even more than its actual price. This way, steel tents are overpriced items and act as a luxury requirement.
The light aluminum tents keep your pockets heavy. Being ergonomic and easy to transport makes them a budget-friendly option. Moreover, they require less maintenance, which keeps your budget in hand. Although their purchasing cost could be higher depending on the quality and brand, compared to the durability, they are still valuable.
Customization
Being sturdy and durable, steel tents are perfect for huge and heavy installations. Large, complicated & industrial setups can easily be constructed on their poles as they provide full support and stability. Besides this, due to high weight, accessories require intensive labor. Moreover, the overall structure usually lacks fine detailing.
Aluminum tents are perfect for modern, minimal style decorations. Being light and user-friendly, they allow easy installation, accessible customization, and fine detailing. Also, there are more choices available for designs and shapes of accessories.
Utilization
Steel tents are perfect for these uses and places:
Permanent installations:
Permanent installations require stability and durability as the top priority. Examples are:
- Warehouses
- Construction sites
- Event venues
Extreme Environments:
The mechanical strength of steel tents equips them to withstand extreme weather conditions and environmental effects. They are suitable for regions with
- Ice storm and heavy snowfall
- Sandstorm and high winds
- Seismic disturbances, like a minor earthquake
The suitability of aluminium tents is reserved for these requirements and areas:
Temporary installations:
As aluminum tents are easy to handle with seamless mobility, they are perfect for events where quick setup and more customization are required for a short time. Such as:
- Trade shows
- Open markets
- Weddings
Moist environments:
As they possess natural resistance towards rust, they withstand wet and salty environments. Compared to steel tents, these are widely used in these areas:
- Coastal regions
- Tropical areas
Parameters to choose?
Steel and aluminum tents both have their own characteristics, insufficiencies, and utilization. You can consider these parameters to select the right one:
- Strength & stability
- Arrangement & usage
- Environmental efficiency
- Cost & value
Strength & stability:
For a stable structure with durability, steel tents would always be the right choice. These tents withstand chemical and mechanical stress while retaining their properties.
Let’s consider these:
- If you require a portable logistics inventory or
- If you want a permanent event site
In both cases, you need a setup with long-term quality and stability. Among the two, steel tents are best for all these purposes, providing reliability and strength.
Arrangement & usage:
For quick setup and events that need customization, aluminum tents are suitable. They are lightweight, easy-to-handle, and portable, making frequent relocation, multi-way handling, and different set-ups accessible and easy.
Consider the situation:
- You have to hold an exhibition that requires setup with multiple sections, lighting, and some decoration, or
- You need a portable setup for a wedding event. It requires detailed customization, a seating arrangement, and a food serving area
As both situations show a few-hour-long event, you would prefer aluminum tents, as they offer customization and frequent mobility.
Environmental efficiency:
Having stability, strength, and resistance towards chemical and mechanical forces, steel tents are perfect for harsh or extreme environments, such as:
- Heavy snow loads and thunderstorms
- Sand storm
- Seismic activity, such as shocks or jolts
On the other hand, aluminum tents can resist corrosion naturally, so these are suitable for these areas:
- Seaside areas
- Tropical regions
Cost & value:
The initial price of steel tents doesn’t matter in most cases. These tents require periodic repair to prevent rust and ensure maintenance. So, if you buy this at a low cost, the charges for every repair keep adding up. This way, steel tents are costly and have little value.
On the other hand, aluminium tents require the least maintenance. So, if you buy a costly tent, this may give you high-quality material and long-term use. The one-time cost of an aluminum tent would be less than the total cost of a steel tent.
Whether you have to consider a steel tent or an aluminium one, both possess separate characteristics. Your needs and environment lead you to make a choice between them. Steel tents possess extra strength and reliability and are best for extreme environments and long-term usage. Whereas aluminum tents, being corrosion-resistant, flexible, and easily transportable, are suitable for wet areas and quick & short-duration setup.
FAQ’s
Q1. What is a steel tent?
Steel tents are tents that possess high weight and increased strength. They are used for permanent installations. The steel gives them resistance against a number of elements, making them durable.
Q2. What is an aluminum tent?
Aluminium tents are lightweight tents. They are suitable for portable and short-term setups. They have enough stability to withstand regular wind and weather.
Q3. What are some dominating features of a steel tent?
They are highly stable and kept fixed in the ground even during a storm. Their durability makes them resistant to temperature, weather, tension, and fire.
Q4. What are some dominating features of an aluminum tent?
They are flexible and can be relocated easily. Moreover, they are tough to corrosion, water, and tension.
Q5. What are the parameters to choose the right tent?
The following are the parameters that should be considered when one has to choose between the steel tent and the aluminium tent:
- Strength & stability
- Arrangements and usage
- Environmental efficiency
- Cost & value